House of Clues – Part 2
by
Tommy Linarcos
Everyone met in the dining room, again. Scott had brought out the Doritos and Pringles. Everyone took a moment to snack, take a sip, or dig for that last chicken leg.
Mia asked if they were ready, then set the timer for Round 3.
“Hey, can I ask you something?” Rory put to Johnny, but then they both watched the others move around them. Lyla took Fiona into Johnny’s bedroom, the Library; Scott saw his opportunity and took Mia into his bedroom, the Study.
“Looks like it’s me and you,” Johnny said.
Rory looked around at the dining room/Dining Room. “I’ve got this room already, though,” he said and moved them both into the frontroom — the Hall — where Conor was making some noises, but still not awake. “In the Hall, I suspect… Col. Mustard in the Hall with the Wrench.”
“Are we really still playing?” Johnny asked.
“Hey, Lyla’s cheating. I’m trying to at least give her a run!”
Johnny showed Rory all his cards, so Rory did the same.
“You had a question,” Johnny reminded him.
“Yeah,” Rory hesitated. “I was…” He shifted, then came out with it. “Did you fuck Mia when you were with her?”
“No.” Johnny didn’t hesitate, though he was surprised Rory actually asked. Then he went for the semi-honest approach. “Kissed her, and felt her tits, because that’s the game, right?”
Rory nodded. “Tits are fun.”
Johnny wasn’t sure Rory was convinced. He opened his pants and pushed them down. “Taste me.”
“What?”
“Taste me. Mia’s pussy juice would still be on me,” he assured him. “You know I hate rubbers.”
Rory waved him off. “That’s okay.”
“Then taste me, anyway, because we have time, Mr. Green?” Johnny asked.
“I think I can accommodate you, Professor Plum,” Rory smiled and dropped to his knees. He took Johnny’s cock into his mouth and started bobbing. Johnny didn’t let him go for too long. He got hard right away, but he was saving his cum for the next round. As a good friend, Johnny dropped and sucked Rory for a time, too.
Thing was, Johnny could tell that Rory had cum sometime in the very recent past. He couldn’t detect any pussy flavor, but he tasted Rory’s cum. Hand job from Lyla?
Conor moaned something from the couch, something akin to, “What’s goin’ on?”
Johnny told him, “Quiet, Conor. You’re dead.”
“No, I’m not…” Conor argued to the ceiling, very confused. One of his hands was stuck in his pants, which was a good thing, he figured, so he played with his balls. But was he dead? He had a flower in his other hand, so maybe…
“Yes. Yes, you are, Conor,” Rory assured him.
“Oh. Okay.” And Conor went back to sleep, dreaming of what it was like to be a ghost.
“Mrs. White,” Scott said as he held open the door to his own bedroom for Mia.
“Why, thank you, Colonel Mustard. You are quite the gentleman,” Mia countered, entering The Study.
“Not for much longer,” Scott growled as he closed the door.
They played the game quickly; Scott showed Mia the Lead Pipe and Mia showed Scott her Prof. Plum.
Mia was fairly certain Scott wasn’t going to try and fuck her. But maybe she could… “So, Scott, is there any chance I could check out your real lead pipe?”
“Mia, you’ve been making hints like that since you and Rory went on the double-date with me and Fiona,” Scott shook his head. “Every time they have us both over at their house at the same time…”
“I can’t help it,” Mia shrugged. “You’re just so hot.”
“And you’re dangerous,” Scott observed.
Mia had a flash that she’d been told that before. How true was it? “We’re just playing a game.”
“Aren’t we, though?” Scott looked her over and said, “So, in the spirit of the game, of course you can. But I get to see those titties and that landing strip.”
Mia was a little surprised that Scott knew the shape of her pubes, but agreed quickly with a smile. “Timer’s running. Let’s see who can take ‘em off the fastest!”
Shirts came off first, of course, and Mia’s bra. Pants were undone and pushed down with underwear.
Mia looked longingly at “sexy” Scott’s pecs, abs, and, as his boxer briefs came down, cock. “Oh, yesss…” she breathed. This isn’t a boy, it’s a man, she thought. His pubes were trimmed to a Speedo regulation, but it was evident he didn’t shave. His cock was bigger than Johnny’s, and she knew how much she wanted Johnny’s… “Can you make it hard for me?” she asked.
“Mia, you are as fantastic as Johnny said. Give it a second and my cock will be hard enough to nail hammers for… er, hammer nails for you,” Scott gave her back. And it soon was. “We have time for more, you know.”
“What about Fiona?” Mia asked.
“We have a game allowance. We discussed this before the first round. I can’t fuck her brother’s girlfriend,” he told her, “but I’d love to feel those titties.”
“And I’d love to taste that cock.”
He sat and made her join him on his bed. They silently agreed she should be sideways so he could reach her breasts easier as she licked his cock base to crown. Her tits were soft and supple, and her skin was flushed — her whole body was turning pink, making her very red nipples stand out. His hand glided down to her dark landing strip. “This is cute!” he said, pulling on her thick curls, then dipped a finger inside her.
She pulled off his cock. “Don’t make me cum. I’m on a hair-trigger and… I don’t want to cum until I’m with… I just need to be with Rory today…”
Scott realized there was more at play than just how far he was allowed to go within his and Fiona’s guidelines. And he realized it meant bad news for his brother, too. “It’s okay.”
He withdrew his finger from her snatch, and put it in his mouth while she watched. “It’s a shame. I’d love to get down in there and make you cum five times before I fucked you into oblivion.”
“Fuck, don’t say that…!”
Scott smiled in a lost victory. “Just don’t get drunk at one of our parties and wander into my bedroom. You won’t come out until noon the next day.”
Mia breathed in deeply and fell flat on her back.
“You giving up?” he asked as he pulled up his sweats.
“Giving up, not giving in.” She pulled up her pants, too. “But I just have to touch you some more.”
“You’ve got until the bell. Then that’s it, forever.”
“I know.”
In Johnny’s bedroom, Lyla and Fiona actually took the first minute to look around the place — at his book titles, his action figures, his posters, his awards and trophies, some lighting that looked like it came from a Tron movie, his cello case shoved in the corner, his guitar more carefully positioned. Lyla noted what was on his desk and that his computer was signed out. The book on his nightstand was Andrew Smith’s Winger. They both checked the softness of his bed.
“Never been in here before?” Lyla asked.
“No. First time,” Fiona responded, spinning his globe. “You?”
“First time I’ve been to his house,” Lyla said.
Fiona found a photo of Lyla, and another of her with friends, and another. A couple of Mia, or Mia and Rory, a group shot Johnny was in, but the one of Lyla was prominent. “You’ve made his bulletin board.”
Lyla came over to see. “Halloween,” she grinned. “And the day after…”
“This is a nice shot,” Fiona said of the first photo.
It was Lyla in the school cafeteria, looking off into the distance, a smile on her face, the end of a laugh. Candid. She was talking to Mia and had no idea Johnny was taking her picture.
She had that look on her face right then.
She shook her head and thought about the game. She had a harder time seeing Fiona’s cards than anyone else’s, and only got Mr. Green out of her, so she only gave Col. Mustard.
They sat on the bed. Lyla ran her hands over Johnny’s Batman pillow.
“You and Scott are such a good couple,” Lyla observed. “Like the whole school wishes they were you two.”
“I don’t think it’s quite that way,” Fiona countered in humility. But aware of the social circles in the school, she knew it was kind of true, though.
“Or wish they could be between you two,” Lyla hinted. “You’re so pretty…” She let her hands run up Fiona’s legs and under her skirt. “Would you be open to a threesome? I won’t ask if you’d rent Scott out.”
“Actually, you might get lucky on that one, today,” Fiona hinted back. “When one of us does something with our friends, we have to balance it out, so…” Fiona pulled up her skirt, revealing her pussy.
“So, if I fuck you, someone might get to fuck me?” she asked, inserting herself between Fiona’s thighs.
“That’s the idea. Now let’s see if you’re better than your sister at this.”
Lyla smiled. “Mine’s the same color,” she said of Fiona’s blond delta. “Just a little curlier. Want to see?”
“You bet I do.”
Lyla wasted no time removing her clothing. Fiona helped the situation by removing hers, as well.
“Lyla, you’re adorable,” Fiona said, immediately appreciating her breasts. She reached out and touched them both and, with a little pressure, drew Lyla to her on the bed.
Lyla tried to speak, but lost her words. She laughed, then fell to holding Fiona, letting her hands roam over her stomach and up to her breasts, as well. “I’ve only ever seen you like… like even close to this, when we all changed at the pool… or little glimpses here and there when you slept over with Tori.”
“Did you ever want to join us?” Fiona asked, one hand on Lyla’s breast, the other massaging Lyla’s ass.
“Every time, but first for the girl talk and secrets and teenager stuff, you know?” she laughed. “But Tori would never let me hang with you both that long. I could only get what I got when you were watching TV in the frontroom or we made snacks in the kitchen.” She looked down Fiona’s body, gazing at her pussy and legs down to her feet. “But I never thought I’d actually get to touch you like Tori did. Does? Did?”
Fiona rolled her eyes. “Does. Now and then.”
Lyla continued to fondle Fiona’s breast, lifting the swell of her breast, then summiting at her nipple with a little pinch. “I wish I had your body…”
“You do,” Fiona noted. “Or you do, two years ago. I love how your nipples have spread… all pink and…”
“That’s because it’s warm in here, and I’m incredibly turned on,” Lyla knew. “I want to just hold you.” Her hand slipped down into Fiona’s pubes, all four fingers twirling in them, and then dipped inside her cleft. “And get you off.”
“Only girls know how we need it done,” Fiona said. “Oooh, you found her…!”
“She stood up to meet me,” Lyla smiled, dipping her fingers inside Fiona and running back along her labia. “Are we watching the clock?”
“The boys will want us back, I know, but I think we can be a little late,” Fiona grinned. “But, with that in mind, I’d really like to taste you. Come here…”
Fiona gently but firmly pulled Lyla into position above her. Lyla was no stranger to the position, though she’d been on the bottom more often with Mia. She adjusted her knees’ position with Fiona’s assistance and lowered her pussy to Fiona’s mouth, giving her control. But in front of her was the secret she’d never seen this close, and couldn’t wait to taste, herself. Both tongues met labia at about the same time, and there was a communal “Um-Mmmmm…” moan.
Lyla wanted to float as Fiona’s intelligent tongue drew her inside herself, but she knew she had her own intense job to perform. Up and back, inside, swirling and sucking at the clitoris, monitoring the taste of her juices, finding when her cum was building. She inserted one, then two fingers, beginning a finger-fuck, making those juices flow.
Lyla wished she had some of her toys available. Johnny had a sister away at college, and Lyla briefly thought about running over to her bedroom to see if she had any. What she really wished for was more time with Fiona. Now that the “ice” was broken, and Fiona told her she still did it with Tori now and again, perhaps there would be opportunity in the future. She’d love to spend more than ten or fifteen minutes making Fiona cum, and having Fiona make her cum.
She was thinking too much, working on Fiona more than letting Fiona get her off. She knew from playing with Mia that getting off was not selfish — your partner needed you to experience the pleasure they were giving, or hoped they were giving.
She went on auto and just let her tongue play. Fiona’s pelvis was riding the waves as much as hers was, now! Push it! There it is!
Fiona fought the battle of letting go and cumming for Lyla, too, while still manipulating her. Lyla had such a cute, pink pussy, lips not too stretched, yet. She tasted like her sister, Fiona determined, but that was a good thing. Could she make Lyla cum like her sister? Could Lyla make her cum like her sister could?
Lyla was picking up speed, double-fingering Fiona’s pussy, pleasuring her g-spot. Fiona’s head was starting to swim, and focused on sucking Lyla’s clit, circling it, and running her hands up to her breasts, pinching and teasing those flat nipples to little points.
And there it goes! Yes! Both of us…!
During their tremors, Fiona was the one who could wrap her arms entirely about the other and press her tightly to her, enjoying that pussy right on her face. Lyla, meanwhile, moaned and floundered between Fiona’s legs, moving a thigh to become a pillow as she nearly passed out, still stroking Fiona’s labia lightly, so lightly…
They’d be a little late for the bell. The others would understand.
* * *
The timer bell went off, and Rory and Johnny waited to greet the others as they arrived back in the dining room. Then they waited a little more. Johnny smiled at the utterly relaxed expression on Lyla’s and Fiona’s faces, their clothing looking somehow softer, now. Rory tried to read Mia’s and Scott’s faces as they arrived, a little blush to them, but Mia did look happy to see him there.
“How we all doing?” Rory asked. “Anyone close to solving who killed Conor?”
“I was disappointed it wasn’t me,” Johnny shook his head, reaching for some Doritos.
“Really?” Fiona commented with raised eyebrows, then she and Rory both marked Prof. Plum off their lists.
The last of the Kool-Aid was poured into the cups. They’d found detective work to be thirsty business. Scott headed into the kitchen with the empty pitcher.
“You ever notice,” Johnny said, looking at the Kool-Aid, “that grape stuff never actually tastes like grapes?”
Lyla grew a big smile. “Yeah, actually, I have! It doesn’t taste ‘grape,’ it tastes ‘purple.’ Like what purple must taste like if it really was a flavor!”
“Like grape Bubble Yum. I used to love that stuff!” Johnny remembered.
“Do they still sell that?” Lyla asked.
“I don’t know. Haven’t had it in a long while,” he realized. “What would blue taste like?” he wondered aloud, then blushed, realizing that Lyla was wearing a blue shirt. “I didn’t…”
“I know,” she said. Still, she looked at Mia and Johnny watching them, and then the boy on the couch. “Is Conor okay?” Lyla asked, concerned he hadn’t moved.
“Yeah. He came to for a bit, but then he died again,” Johnny half-explained.
“What happened? Really?”
“He’s so high, right now,” Rory really explained. “He’d been eating those edibles like they were candy, so he’s going to be high for the whole day. We made him take a nap to burn some of it off, but he’s only been down for about, I don’t know, an hour, maybe two hours, now?”
“He’ll be fine,” Johnny told Lyla, taking her hand, making it clear they were partnering up. Rory caught what Johnny did, and put his arms around Mia from behind while she reset the timer.
“Round 4, then,” Mia called, and moved with Rory into Johnny’s bedroom — the Library.
Fiona headed into the kitchen and kissed the back of Scott’s neck. He’d just cleaned and refilled the pitcher with water and mixed-in some cherry Kool-Aid mix. He was in the process of adding sugar.
“Here, taste this,” he asked Fiona, and had her sip from a big spoon.
“Little more, or add some lemon to it,” she advised.
“Good idea.” He did both, plus ice, and then he put the pitcher in the refrigerator. “Are we paired up again? This is our second time. I’ve already shown you all my cards.”
“Yeah, the others ditched us,” Fiona said. “I think this was supposed to be my turn with Mia.”
Scott dried his hands and wrapped his arms around his girl. “You don’t have much to balance out, but if you really want to, it won’t be difficult. She’s at your house often enough.”
“You’ll have some fun with Lyla. She’s got the family talent,” Fiona giggled.
“Yeah?”
“Yeah…”
“But will this shut her up, or make her want more?” he asked.
“Doesn’t matter. It’s the only chance she’s gonna get,” Fiona said, and kissed her guy. “Hey, I brought over a course catalog from Duke I got in the mail. Take a look at it with me.”
In Johnny’s bedroom, Rory and Mia were still playing the game, but like the others, just traded cards, trying to beat Lyla at her own game. “Ooh, I only need one more to find the room,” Rory declared.
“I only need one more to get the weapon,” Mia added.
“That’s done, then.” Rory pulled off his green Sandman shirt and whipped back the blue-and-white covers on Johnny’s bed. “Now take your clothes off and get in this bed.”
Mia’s heart raced with the thrill. “Yes, sir!” She was pulling her white top over her head when Rory stopped her progress, holding her arms steady, keeping the shirt covering the top of her face. He came close enough to kiss her, but licked her lips, instead. She moved like she wanted to bite him, but couldn’t find him, couldn’t kiss him, as he’d backed his face away.
He released her arms, but trusted them to stay where he’d left them. Mia was turned-on enough to keep them raised, wanting to find out what he was up to. He undid the latch on her bra and lifted the cups so he could nuzzle and suck on her breasts. She let her arms down out of her shirt so she could remove her bra, but kept the shirt over her face, like a mask, like…
“Look up. I’m Spider-Gwen!”
“Careful,” Rory said, releasing a nipple. “She’s my fantasy girl. I would love to fuck Gwen Stacy.”
Mia thought about the girl from the animated movie they’d seen, and shook her head. “I’ll fuck you upside-down, but I’m sorry, I can’t do that stuff to my hair like she has.” She took off her ‘mask.’
“No worries,” Rory said, opening her pants. “I love my dark-haired beauty.” He pulled down her pants and panties, revealing her dark landing strip. “Is it… okay?… if I ask what you’ve been up to, so far, in the game?”
Mia was ready for that. “Oh, yeah. Not too much. Lyla and I really just made sure we looked good, and talked about what we would do and not do.”
“Yeah, I got that from her,” Rory said, pulling Mia’s pants off her feet.
“Then with Johnny… oh, just messed around a bit. It was the game. He played with my boobs. He knows.”
Rory nodded. That lined-up. He looked at the Spider-Man and Batman pillow cases that had been hidden under the mature and stylish comforter, and smiled. He knew he liked Johnny for something. “Then… Scott?”
“You trust me, right?” she asked her boyfriend.
“Of course,” he replied right away. “And I know Scott loves Fiona, but it’s the game, and I’m just wondering.” He took off Mia’s socks.
“You took my socks off. We’re staying awhile, huh?” she asked, running her foot up his chest as he dropped his pants. He grabbed her ankle and kissed her arch.
“Yeah. I asked Johnny if he minded. He’s cool with it,” Rory said. He held her foot and played with her toes. “You know, you have some cute little tootsies, but if you were naked, with just Gwen’s light-blue Converse sneakers, I would cum so hard…”
“Good to know,” she smiled from the bed and made a mental note to find those online, later.
Rory let her foot go and dropped his boxers.
“Release the Kraken…” Mia sang quietly to him, gazing at his cock. Rory then sat to pull off his boxers and pants along with his own socks. Mia got to her answer. “Scott… I couldn’t pass up the chance to see him naked.”
“Fiona said today was the day, like a hall pass day for both of them, within the limits of the game, or whatever.” He reached back for his pants before he forgot something.
“That’s right. You were with Fiona, already. So, did you finally get to fuck your sister?” she teased.
“No,” Rory shook his head and gave her the eye, “she only gave me a blowjob.”
“Sure…”
“So,” he re-prompted her, “he saw you naked?” He took a Trojan out of a pocket, then slipped it under the pillow.
“Yeah, and a little touching. Had to. I mean,” she sat up and looked Rory in the eye, “you’ve seen him. I had to touch those pecs. And his cock? I think it’s bigger than Johnny’s.”
“It is.” Rory knew this from experience, but he still wasn’t sure he wanted to tell Mia that tale.
Mia ran her hands down Rory’s body and made him fall back on the bed and join her lengthwise. She took his cock in her hands. It was the best looking cock she’d ever encountered. Not as big as Johnny’s or Scott’s, but very smooth, his scar ring so light it almost wasn’t there, and his head got so purple when he was excited, especially when she held the base tightly. His balls were big, but didn’t hang ugly. And he had those blond pubes. Honey-colored pubes. For some reason, she just thought that was so cool.
“And yes, I couldn’t pass up tasting Scott’s cock.” She took Rory’s cock into her mouth and sucked on his crown, licking around the corona.
“Like that?” Rory asked.
“Yes, but…” she pulled off him, “then I stopped.” She licked Rory’s cock down his shaft to his balls. “But I don’t want to stop on you.”
“You’re going to have to, because I am dying to fuck you.” He ran his hands the length of her hair and pulled her back.
“Rory, I just want you to know,” Mia said, very seriously, “that I am going to explode the second your cock penetrates me. Like, I will be dead, after, because I will have actually exploded. Do you understand?”
“Yes,” he said, “and I am ready to kill you. Mr. Green in the…” he looked around and saw Johnny’s books, “in the Library with the Knife.” He stroked his cock for her.
She rubbed her legs together at her crotch. “With Lyla and Johnny and Scott all teasing me, I am just so ready to cum, like… waiting for you… it’s… if you just touched my pussy, right now, I would scream.”
Rory pulled Mia back down onto her back and flipped on top of her, shoving her shoulders to the sheets. He kicked her legs open with his knees and pressed his cock down on her. “Just a touch?”
“Oh, fuck, Rory…”
“Mia…” he got her attention, “I’m going in bare, and you can’t stop me.”
Mia drew in a quick breath. God, she wanted him bare. They’d been very good about condom use since their pregnancy scare, but she loved how he felt without one. “No, Rory…”
“Fuckin’ yes Rory…” he muttered and slid his cock into her sopping wet pussy.
“Oh, fffffuck…! Fuck me!” she cried and, like she warned, began to convulse. The feeling of being filled by the boy she loved when she was this fucking horny made her cum instantly. She had to tell him. She had to tell him today. He’d waited for her to come around, finally, and give in to love. They understood each other too well. She had to tell him today.
Rory stabbed into her again and again as her flood began, her fluids splashing out of her pussy each time. He figured he was good for a little while or at least a minute or two before he would have to honestly wrap up his cock. Or maybe this first time was one of those when he could just pull out and cum on her tits. Yeah.
“That’s my baby. Fuckin’ cum for me…”
“Oh, fuck, Rory… Hold me…”
“I’m gonna fuckin’ cum inside you.”
“No, no!” she whined and started to sit up, not sure if it was just dirty talk or if he really was going to.
He pushed her shoulders back down to the sheets. “Yes, Mia. Or… maybe I’ll cum on your tits…”
She lit up at that. Inside, she knew that was his plan, but loved the dirty talk about it. And the thought of it, honestly, made her cum a little more. “Oh, yeahhhh… cum on my tits, Rory… cum on my tits…”
Rory fucked her faster, bringing himself to the edge earlier than he wanted, but it would feel so good. He reached that point where he could try to calm down, or just go for it. He pulled his cock out and fired jet after jet of cum all over her body.
“Oh, Rory, oh I fucking love that!” Mia moaned, spreading the cum out as it hit her. “Will you clean me off?” she asked.
He wasn’t going to let her take control back, though. “No, you clean me off.” He moved around next to her and offered her his cock, which she took inside her mouth without thinking, holding tightly onto his ass.
“Your pussy looks too cute to be left alone, though,” he told her body as he spun a bit and put himself above her, sixty-nining, and licked her clean there, instead.
Johnny took Lyla’s hand. He figured Scott would take Fiona into his own bedroom, and he’d given his bedroom to Rory and Mia. They could take his sister’s room, or they could really try the quickie-in-a-closet thing. There was the front hall coat closet, or the pantry in the kitchen. He headed to the closet for the “classic” feel of Seven Minutes in Heaven. “This way, Mrs. Peacock.”
“Where are we go-…? Oooh! Professor Plum!” Lyla squeaked as Johnny opened the door, pushed back a row of coats, and pulled her inside with him. They kicked some shoes and boots out of their way and Johnny closed the door.
Lyla threw her arms around him — half for passion, half for stability in the dark. “This is cozy. I can smell your leather bomber jacket.”
“You know it’s mine?” He could barely see her eyes in the dark, but there was just enough light leaking through the bottom and cracks in the door to make out her face.
“Yeah. It looks good on you.” She felt along his body. “Hey, I can’t see your cards in here.”
“Study, Wrench, Lounge,” he just flat-out told her hair, letting his hands find her breasts.
Lyla repeated the clues three times, committing them to memory. “Thaaaank you… For that, I’ll give you Revolver,” she said, her hand finding his hard cock.
“I’ll give you Revolver…” he groaned, putting his hand over hers and mashing it against him, keeping her there.
“Don’t tease me, Johnny.”
“I’m not teasing,” he whispered in her ear. “Now… where were we? Where’d we leave off?” His hands popped the button on her pants. “Oh, yes… Operation… Dr. Lyla… I was naked on Mia’s bed, your wet pussy was humping my leg, and you were sucking on my cock, giving me the best blowjob I’d ever…”
Lyla shut him up with a kiss, tongue snaking toward his throat. She broke for air. “Shut up. We’ve only got nine minutes. I’ve been waiting weeks to feel your cock inside me.” She was working on his pants, too.
Their hands and his wrist brace were getting in each other’s way, so he pushed her against the back wall and let her work. He moved up her double t-shirts — her own pink one and Scott’s blue one on top of that, though he couldn’t see either color in the dark. She was braless, he found, much to his delight. He couldn’t see them, but he could imagine the light-light-pinkiness of her nipples. He wanted to suck on them, again, but Lyla was moving, pushing his pants and boxers down.
She stood and finished undoing her own pants, not waiting for Johnny to take over. She pushed them and her panties to her knees, then hesitated. She could just turn and have him take her from behind, or… She pushed them down all the way and stomped her feet out of the legs. She stood, and Johnny’s hands went to her ass.
“I want to be able to kiss you,” she explained. “I don’t want to hit my face on the wall. I wish I could see your eyes, but this way I can… Can we do it this way?”
“Yeah, pretty sure,” he said, his hand slipping around to her pussy. He dipped a finger inside, then brought it up to his mouth. “So that’s what blue tastes like.”
“You’re bad,” she said, shaking her head.
“Well, blue like your eyes,” he said, though he couldn’t see the actual color at that point.
“Blue like your eyes,” Lyla dreamed, then kissed him again.
They were pressed together and Johnny hunched down to get his cock below her and played it along her center, finding her pubes then going south. “You’re dripping wet,” he wondered aloud.
“Fiona and I sixty-nined. She is sssso good. I’ve always wanted to fuck Fiona. Now I want to fuck you,” she said, bouncing her hips, trying to make him move inside her.
Johnny found her entrance easily and speared inside. Both of them moaned some version of “Oh, fuck….” He rose up, taking Lyla with him. She went to her tiptoes, giving him as much room as she could as he thrust from below.
Johnny inhaled deeply. He was inside Lyla. He just took a moment to hold onto the feeling. This was the girl he wanted. And not just because she was unavailable, but he knew they were meant to be together. Here they were having sex, kissing, loving each other, but only for ten minutes — then they had to go back to the party and go back to the way things were. He wasn’t going to screw things up by declaring love, though. He’d just make this the best ten minutes he could.
He first tried to pick her up, holding her under her ass, but it wasn’t working well; he had the strength, and she was light enough, but the room — or lack of it with the pole over their heads — just wasn’t helping.
He turned them both, her rear toward the side wall, her head against the softness of his bomber jacket, and held her left leg up under his elbow and arm brace. “Ah, that’s it…” He was able to get in nice and deep, feeling her golden curls rub against his lower belly.
“Oh, god, yes… I knew it… fuck me, Johnny… I’ve been… I’ve wanted… oh, fuck yes!” she moaned as he pounded her against the wall.
“We should have tried this at Mia’s Halloween party,” he breathed in her ear. Mia’s parents had been home, so a closet would have been the only privacy.
“You’re so bad…” she said, amid whimpering.
“But Lyla… you feel so good…” Johnny’s other hand held her waist, but she was steady, so he happily found her breast, again.
“Hey, I loved your video,” she said directly in his ear, biting his lobe. “So hot…”
“I made that for you,” he told her.
“Mia had the camera, though, right?” she asked with a little knowledge.
“But I was talking to you,” he promised her.
She caught her breath as he went in for that kiss. They were actually at the perfect height.
“Johnny… your cock… oh, my god… keep going… just keep… just like that… yeah…”
Johnny’s attention was on kissing Lyla and maintaining that driving rhythm below. Lyla tasted good, he thought, and she really knew how to kiss. They worked well together. Then he had that stray thought, the one about ‘do I keep going, ‘cause if I do, I’m going to blast cum into this girl…’ “Lyla, I’m sorry, baby, I need to get that rubber or I’m gonna cum in you. We went in so fast, I…”
“No, don’t you pull out! I’m fine. Don’t stop fucking me!”
“You sure?”
“Positive!”
I’ll take her word for it. With that, Johnny picked up the pace, pounding her ass into the wall, shaking the house. Everyone knew someone was getting action. Conor, on the couch, may have incorporated an earthquake into his dream.
“Oh-oh-oh… yes… Johnny,” she squeaked, holding onto him tighter around his neck and shoulders as she came. Her one foot on the floor was slipping as her hips quivered, but Johnny was holding her steady against the wall.
Johnny’s cock got a whole lot wetter. “You cumming for me? Lyla? You cumming for me?”
“Fuck, yes!… I’m cumming I’m cumming… I’m finally cumming for you…” she moaned weakly, giving all her weight to Johnny.
Johnny took that as his cue. “Then… I’m gonna cum in you…”
“Yes… cum in me… I want to feel it… I want to feel you cum in me…”
Johnny held her as tightly as she was holding him and clenched his jaw. His orgasm hit and he held his cock still inside her as his body spasmed and pumped out jets of his cum. Around the fourth blast, and after Lyla’s “I feel it… I feel it!” he needed to fuck, again, and resumed driving his hips into her a little longer.
Then he let her leg down. He stayed inside her, but let her leg rest and massaged her hip. Both of them were breathing heavy. Adjusted to the dark now, he lifted her face and, finding the glint in her eyes, kissed her.
“Johnny, why can’t you be my boyfriend?” Lyla laughed in her recovery.
“Because you’re going out with Jughead out on the couch,” Johnny reminded her.
“Conor can be sweet,” she finished laughing.
“Yeah, he’s okay,” Johnny gave in. “Are you sure you’re okay? I mean…” He nodded below, but Lyla really couldn’t tell in the dark. “I must’ve cum a gallon into you. Unless the old story about not being able to get pregnant if you do it standing up is true…!”
“No, I… um… today was my day.” She was smiling, and he could tell that she was, his lips were so close. She pulled him tighter and kissed him, again. “After Mia and Rory had that pregnancy scare back in September — you weren’t there — I had a talk with my sister, Tori. She took me to her doctor, and I went on the pill. It takes a month for it to be effective, like my monthly to next monthly.” She didn’t want to use more precise, less sexy words, but wanted him to know. “So, I was debating whether, when you and me were at Mia’s, whether I should chance it, but I stuck it out, like the doctor said. And today I’m good. And you are the first boy I’ve ever had cum inside me!”
She kissed him, again and again, and he joined her. “It’s my honor!” he proclaimed.
They pulled away and began to straighten themselves, deciding it would be easier to do outside the closet. Johnny immediately felt the loss, and wondered if she felt the same. She had to, he believed. He opened the door and Lyla found her pants. “Can you help me? I don’t want to sit on your nice chairs with all our stuff leaking out of me!” Lyla half-joked.
The bell in the dining room dinged.
Johnny pulled a girl’s pants right-side-out for the second time that day and presented her panties to her. Conor was silent, no matter whether he was conscious or still pleasantly on another metaphysical plane.
“We good?” Johnny asked.
Lyla assured him she was, but, “Next time, we get a bed!”
Next time, she’d said; Johnny liked the sound of that.
He kissed her again. He decided that kissing her was really his favorite part, even more than the sex they just had. He loved kissing her, and her kissing him back. He led her back to the dining room, holding her hand.
* * *
Scott and Fiona were at the dining table. She sat half in her own chair, her legs across his lap, the college catalog open. He was reading a passage while massaging her right foot. “There they are,” Scott said as Johnny and Lyla entered. “I had to get the toolbox and reattach the chandelier, the place shook so bad!”
“Were you guys here the entire time?” Johnny asked. “You didn’t go in a room?”
“Nah, we have things to discuss. We just talked this round out,” Scott reported.
“Just talk?” Lyla kidded.
“Yeah,” Fiona told her. “You can do that when you really like each other.” She gave her man a kiss, anyway.
“As friends, not just lovers,” he added, and they kissed again.
Lyla got that romantic middle-schooler look on her face and sighed. Johnny wondered if he and Lyla could do that — talk, like he’d proposed to Mia, be alone, be friends beyond sex, beyond the group.
Lyla excused herself to the washroom, telling Johnny she needed to and it was not an invitation for more Clue-ing in the Ballroom.
Johnny waved at Scott. “Hey, come here. Got to tell you something.”
Scott excused himself from under Fiona and followed Johnny into his own bedroom. “What’s up?” he asked, closing the door.
Johnny opened his pants. “Did you really want to taste which girl is on me?”
Scott laughed. “It’s kind of obvious, I think.” He was going to turn and head back out, but caught a look on Johnny’s face. “Wait — did you really want me to?”
Johnny shrugged. “Well, you made me suck you…”
Scott sighed inside himself. He’d started the whole thing. He got to his knees and met Johnny’s still semi-hard cock, pulling his pants down a little further. He held Johnny’s balls and assessed his cock. “You are a good size. I’d mentioned to Fiona that you were pretty close to my length, and you are.”
He took Johnny’s cock into his mouth and ran his tongue along the shaft. He considered something, then sucked twice more, fully. He pulled off. “So that’s Lyla?”
“Yeah.” Johnny decided not to mention anything about Mia, the same as he hadn’t to Rory.
“Tastes like her sister,” Scott dropped off-hand.
“You did Tori?” Johnny asked.
“Yeah. Fiona had a threesome fantasy, and I gave in,” he laughed. With that, he stood up, and Johnny put himself back together. All set, they went back out to the dining table.
Johnny replenished some salt in his body and finished the Pringles. Scott told him there was more Kool-Aid in the ‘fridge. Johnny got the pitcher and brought it back out to the table and poured. He picked up a piece of chicken; the legs and thighs were gone, so he chose a breast. Conor could have all the wings when he woke up.
Soon, Lyla rejoined them, and marked down Johnny’s cards on her Clue sheet. Johnny tore off a piece of the breast and popped it in Lyla’s mouth, then kissed her.
“Still missing one of your cards,” Lyla over-hinted to Fiona.
“Oh, here…” Fiona said, and flipped up her Knife card. Lyla clapped her hands with a he-he!
“What are we doing with the ‘real’ weapons?” Fiona asked Lyla about the items on top of the game board. “You brought them. Is there a purpose?”
“They were just for fun. Didn’t know if they could come in handy,” she remarked, shrugging. She picked up the wrench and turned it over, wondering.
“Fix the curve in Conor’s cock?” Johnny guessed. Lyla just rolled her eyes. Johnny picked up the turkey baster / Lead Pipe. He squished the bulb on the end. “Cum getter-outer?”
“Yuck!” Lyla winced.
Fiona groaned, “One of the smartest kids in school, but he’s still only fifteen when you get down to it…”
Scott picked up the Nerf gun and shot a suction dark at Johnny’s forehead.
“Hey, don’t shoo- Oh, wait, I don’t have my contacts in,” Johnny said, picking up the dart and throwing it.
“Why not?” Scott asked, swatting the dart away.
“Everyone was here after I showered. Just didn’t.”
“Where are your glasses, then?”
Johnny went and got them from a table in the frontroom. “Hey, you look good in those,” Lyla remarked with enthusiasm. “You could wear them more often.”
“No, only when my eyes are tired of wearing the contacts,” Johnny said.
Lyla turned his face toward her and looked into his eyes, studying them. “They’re still so blue. I wondered if the contacts… But no. That’s you.”
Johnny let her keep looking a bit longer.
“Did you have your contacts in when you got tackled and hurt your hand last month?” Scott asked. “You didn’t play blind that day, did you?”
“No, I had them in. That was just that asswipe from LaGrange. That’s healed. I’ve worn this thing religiously,” Johnny said.
“Su pobre mano,” Lyla said in bad first-year Spanish, playing with his fingers. “Your handwriting sucks with this thing.”
“My cursive, but my printing’s okay-ish, mi corazón,” Johnny noted. “But I have gotten better at jerking off with my left hand…”
Lyla swatted at him. “Did you have that on at Halloween?” she asked.
“Yeah. Under my suit.” His left arm went around her.
“If you’d have told me you were dressing as the Mad Hatter, I could have been Alice, you know,” she said.
“It was the Batman version of Mad Hatter, though. Would you have known which Alice to be?” he asked.
Lyla traced the Batman logo on his purple t-shirt. “I’m sure you would have helped me.”
“Yeah, I would have,” he admitted. “But it was a last-minute decision. I hate too-complex costumes with props, and you can never sit down, or dance. But I had a top hat, found some stupid-looking pants…”
“Last-minute? Were you not going to come to the party?” Lyla asked. “I would have missed you.”
“I was going. Just had too many ideas. James Bond. Malcolm McDowell from Clockwork Orange…”
“Who?”
“See? I don’t know if anyone would have known that,” he said, his fingers in her hair. “You were the one keeping her costume secret, remember? You were really cute as Luna Lovegood. I knew you were a Ravenclaw. I could have dressed up as Cedric, maybe.”
“You’re no Hufflepuff. You’re a Ravenclaw, too, aren’t you?” she asked, not looking away from his eyes. “You gotta be.”
“I took the test. Got 50% Ravenclaw, 50% Slytherin, so could’ve gone as Draco, or Albus Potter.” He slipped his fingers in-between hers, interlocking. Her hand was small, delicate, but she had a little callus above the knuckle of her right middle finger, right where she’d hold a pencil. Just like his.
“You know, this one time, in 8th Grade, I was talking about reading the Harry Potter books, and this boy goes, ‘They have books about him now?’” she recalled, her face animated. Both of them broke into a long laugh.
“That was a lot of fun, that night! And the next day when we all went out…!” Her face had the sparkle of memory.
Johnny looked at Lyla, still holding her hand, and thought about his desire to see if they could just sit and talk and just ‘be’ together, and realized that was their relationship. They had three classes together, though nobody talked in Geometry. When they were together, they shared that gift of curiosity and conversation. He just wanted to add the closeness, the kissing, the partnership to it. Not possession, but dedication. Maybe even love.
“I saw those pictures you took,” she admitted, “on your wall.”
Johnny blushed and shrugged. “How could I not? You looked so…”
Scott and Fiona just watched them. Both knew it was a kiss opportunity, but Johnny missed it.
It got quiet and Scott asked aloud about what they all were waiting on. “Mia and Rory going into overtime?”
“Let ‘em,” Fiona smiled.
“Hey,” Johnny asked Lyla. “That, uh, your thing. Is Mia taking it, too?”
Lyla just shook her head. “I wish she would, though.”
Fiona, her antennae up, caught on even without too many words. Rory had confided in her about their pregnancy scare, about what he could do, which was ‘nothing,’ at the time. “Parents are hard to get around when starting those,” she said.
“Tell me about it,” Lyla said. “My mom would freak, if she knew. If it weren’t for my sister helping me…”
“Tori fought that battle for you, a couple years ago, actually,” Fiona told her. “Got all the arguing out of the way. I’ll bet your mom knows, just isn’t saying anything. Just trusting you.”
Lyla had to consider that.
Johnny thumbed the condom in his pocket, and looked toward his bedroom. “I’m gonna check on them. See if they’re okay.”
“Leave them be,” Lyla requested.
“Don’t worry, I’m not gonna mess with them.” Johnny came to his own bedroom door and knocked. He didn’t wait for a response, just alerted them and went in. “You guys done playing?” he asked.
The shape inside his covers moved, and Rory stuck his head out. “Um… probably?”
Mia’s eyes found the edge of the comforter, too, though her leg and butt were very visible in the twist. It was funny; they’d all been quite naked together before, but she was hiding. It was cute.
“Here,” Johnny said, tossing the foil packet to Rory. “Thought you could use another. Have fun but stay safe.”
All three exchanged smiles, and Johnny left, closing the door behind him. He, too, cleaned up in the washroom before returning to the others. “They’ve got some more, um, detective work to finish up. So… Round 5?”
Scott and Fiona looked in each other’s eyes, shrugged, and gave permission to head off separately. Fiona took Johnny into Scott’s bedroom, so Scott took Lyla into his sister’s room.
Continued in Part 3
Copyright 2025 – Tommy Linarcos
All rights reserved