October 16, 2008

Chasing Colt – Chapter Five – A Challenge!
Alex Hawk

After Tyler was done talking the three of us laid there on my bed, lost in our own thoughts. Bryce said, “That’s probably the hottest story I’ve ever heard.”

“Yeah, it sure got me going,” I muttered. I’d been fingering myself most of the way through the story and the boys had started masturbating each other towards the end.

“So what happened after that?”

Tyler shrugged. “Well, Angelo and I started having sex like every week. Spencer only joined in a couple times. After a while, though, Angelo started hanging out with Isabel some more and he stopped having sex with me. Spencer and me did it by ourselves sometimes, but he wasn’t ever as into it as Angelo was. The last time I had sex with him was about three months ago and the last time with Angelo was about six months.”

“What about Colt and Tobey? How did that happen?” asked Bryce.

Tyler shrugged again. “It was pretty much the same, actually. Except that it happened in my bedroom about eight months ago.”

My mind drifted back. I dimly remembered the two boys staying the night back then. That was when I’d first noticed Colt.

“So you’ve done it with Colt a lot since then?” I asked.

“Yeah, pretty much every chance we can. I only did it a few times with Tobey.”

“How come you haven’t done anything with Storm, Matthew or Ezra yet?”

Tyler shrugged once more. “Just haven’t had the chance.”

Bryce looked over at me. “You oughta try to do each of the boys on the team.”

I raised an eyebrow. “What, you think I’m some sort of slut?”


“Pinch him, Tyler.”

“Ow!” Bryce rubbed at his nipple. “No, seriously. You should see if you can get each of them and then save Colt for last.”

“Yeah, that sounds cool,” said Tyler.

I found myself actually thinking about the idea. “You know… that does sound like it might be interesting. I’ve never devirginized an entire baseball team. I’ve got all of Summer Vacation, I might as well make good use of it.”

“Yeah. And if you pull it off, we can all have a big orgy just before school starts,” put in Bryce.

“That sounds like fun,” I said. I reached over and started idly playing with Tyler’s penis along with Bryce.

“So how come you guys never asked me to join?” Bryce asked, sounding a little hurt.

Tyler winced slightly. “Well… it’s like this. As long as it was us, it wasn’t really sex. We’re all straight, as far as we’re concerned. We knew, I guess, that if you joined us then you’d think it was sex cause you were gay and if that was the case then what were we? I don’t know if anyone really thought it out all the way like that, but I think that’s what it was.”


“Sorry, dude.”

“It’s ok.” Bryce leaned over and kissed Tyler who kissed him back. I sat back and enjoyed the show while masturbating my little brother.

“Amber?” Tyler asked after breaking the kiss.


“Can I fuck you again?”

“Right now?”


“Sure, if you want.”

“Oh, I do.”

As Tyler sat up and started moving over towards me, Bryce said, “Are you seriously going to fuck your own sister again? I mean it was one thing once when you were just supposed to get lube, but doing it again would just be incest.”

“Yeah, but she doesn’t care. Besides, you’re just jealous that I’m going to be fucking her this time and not you.”

Bryce blushed. “Well, yeah, maybe.”

I said to Bryce, “Look. After Tyler cums in me, you can have a turn. I’ve heard it’s even better fucking a girl after someone else has cum inside her.”


“Yeah. I’ve never tried it, but that’s what I’ve heard. Besides, you’ll get to see Tyler’s naked body moving on top of me.”

Bryce considered this. “Ok.”

“Wait, though,” said Tyler. “If I cum inside you, won’t I get you pregnant?”

“You already DID cum inside me, Tyler, so it’s a little late to be worrying about that,” I pointed out.

“Oh, yeah. Sorry about that, by the way.” He blushed, looking really embarrassed.

“It’s no big deal. I’m actually on the Pill, so it’s not a problem, but you should always make sure to ask the girl first.”

“Ok. Can I fuck you now?”

I laughed a little. “What a one track mind. Alright, get into position.”


Once Tyler was on top of me, I said to him, “You think you can get it in on your own, or do you need some help?”

Tyler poked around for a bit and then said, “Is this the right place?”

“A little higher.”



Tyler pushed forward and once again I felt the amazingly odd and erotic sensation of my little brother’s penis sliding up into my vagina. He let out a little moan of pure pleasure and delight as he pushed home.

“Oooh… I can’t believe I’m finally getting to fuck a girl…”

“I can’t believe I’m getting fucked by my own brother,” I said with a little grin, savoring the pleasure between my legs. “Try rotating your hips a little.”

“Like this?” Tyler said, swiveling around.


Bryce got on his knees next to Tyler, putting a hand on my brother’s butt while he fucked me. “It also feels better for her if you push it in as deep a you can go.”

“It does?” Tyler looked down at me. I nodded. “Ok.” He began trying to go in deeper while rotating his hips. “That’s cool… feels better for me, too…”

“Cool,” Bryce said. He leaned his face close to Tyler’s and the two of them kissed for a few moments.

“Hey, Bryce?” Tyler said, breaking the kiss. “Let me suck you while I fuck Amber.”

“Sure, twist my arm,” Bryce said with a grin. He moved closer to Tyler.

Rather awkwardly, my brother leaned his head down and did his best to get Bryce’s penis in his mouth. Eventually he wound up lowering himself further down onto my body until I was supporting almost his entire weight. It meant he also wasn’t fucking me nearly as deep or as hard as before, but the fact that I was watching boysex at close range more than made up for that.

“You really like sucking dick… don’t you, Tyler?” I said, a little out of breath.

Mouth full of penis, Tyler nodded, his eyes closed. He looked very content.

“He’s good at it, too,” whispered Bryce, resting his hand on the back of Tyler’s head.

After a few more minutes, Tyler began really breathing hard. He pulled his mouth off Bryce and started fucking me faster and faster.

“I’m gonna cum soon,” he whispered.

“I’m getting close, too,” I gasped out.

Grunting, Tyler pushed hard into me, and I felt his young penis start kicking around inside my vagina for the second time that day. My brother rested his head on my shoulder and kept shooting spurt after spurt of incestuous sperm up into my waiting body.

This was enough to make me cum, too, and my vagina started grabbing hard at my little brother’s still spurting penis. I held him really tight against me, my hands grabbing hard at his ass and trying with all my effort to get him deeper inside me. It was definitely in the top ten of the best orgasms of my life.

Tyler lifted his head up. “Did you… just cum…?”



“Yeah!” I kissed my brother on the cheek.

“Are we going to be able to… you know… do this some more?”

“Yeah, I think so.”


“Alright!” said Bryce. “Either get off her and let me have my turn, or I’m going to fuck your ass, Tyler.”

“Hmmm…” Tyler said, propping himself up on his elbows and looking thoughtful. “That might be kind of interesting.”

“Oh, really?” Bryce moved behind Tyler and got sort of on top of him. He poked his penis against Tyler’s butt. “You wanna find out just HOW interesting?”

I actually felt Tyler’s penis jump slightly in my vagina, but he said, “Naw… not this time. Maybe next time, though, ok?”

“There will be a next time, then?” Bryce asked, getting off Tyler.

Tyler pulled out of me, sat up a little and kissed Bryce very passionately on the mouth. “Just try to stop me,” he whispered.

Bryce gave a fairly stupid looking grin. “Cool.” He looked down at me. “Are you ready for me?”

“Of course.”


Bryce got on top of me and with no problems at all, slipped his penis easily into my vagina. “Wooo… wow, that is better with Tyler’s cum in here,” he said, giving a couple experimental thrusts.

“Glad you like it,” I said with a grin.

“Can I suck you some more while I fuck her, Tyler?”

Tyler shrugged and got up onto his knees. His penis was mostly soft. “Sure, if you want. But I don’t think I’ll cum again.”

“That’s cool. I just like having your dick in my mouth.”


Tyler moved close and Bryce, not breaking the easy, steady motion of thrusts that he’d began, leaned down and started blowing him. I reached up and put one hand on my brother’s butt and the other one on Bryce’s, feeling that this was possibly the best sex of my life.

Bryce had real staying power, as I’d mentioned before. It wasn’t long before I felt another orgasm approaching for me, and judging by the fact that Tyler was now actively fucking Bryce’s face, I figured he might be getting close, too.

Amazingly, all three of us came within a minute of each other. Tyler came first, moaning loudly and holding onto Bryce’s head. Bryce started swallowing Tyler’s sperm and at the same time began pumping his own sperm into my vagina. This triggered my own orgasm and soon I was milking Bryce’s penis for all I was worth. It was just heavenly!

“Oh, god,” Tyler said, gasping for breath. “I can’t believe… I came again…”

Bryce gave a tired smile. “Yeah… I gotz the mad skillz…”

Finally we were all sated. The boys both collapsed next to me and we all laid there, breathing hard, our minds full of thoughts. We laid there together, our naked bodies wrapped together as we basked in the afterglow of amazing sex. I knew now this was the best sex I’d ever had, and that with my new challenge I could look forward to a lot more good fun.


Copyright 2004 by Alex Hawk. All characters and events depicted are fictional. Any similarity to real people or events is entirely unlikely.